Meet The Important Ones!

Meet The Important Ones!

Illustrator Issues. What should I do?

While browsing the Internet, I decided to spend some time finding out more about publishing for children. More to do with the illustration side. An obvious project for someone writing a book with pictures for children. These are two things I found.
  • My market age group is six to nine years old. (Now I know my genre niche).
  • My illustrations will probably not be used. *Screech, rewind eyes and read again* (Yes you read correctly my precious Polly Poppy and Wallis Worm might never see the light of day).
To quote one site:
  • Unless you are a professional illustrator, we do not recommend including illustrations with your manuscript; an art director, designer or editor will choose a trusted illustrator she thinks suits your work.
  • Do not attempt to indicate where you would like your illustrations placed in your story, or what they should portray. This is the province of the art director, and/or the designer and the illustrator.
To quote another:
  • If you're not a professional artist, don't try to illustrate your book yourself. If you don't have a particular illustrator in mind for your book, you don't need to find one before submitting your manuscript. Publishers often have illustrators they like to work with, and a filing cabinet full of the portfolios of many more that they can contact to illustrate your book if it's accepted. 
 To quote another:

Do I need to find an illustrator?

No, the publisher selects the illustrator. Even though picture books end up with text and illustration seeming to be inseparable, many of them start out as manuscripts, and stay in that form until after a publisher offers a contract to the author. Only then does the publisher select an illustrator, who will typically receive half of the royalties for the book. The publisher works with the illustrator through sketching, layout, and final illustrations, and may not involve the author much in the process. Authors are often unhappy about that, but it's done to let the illustrator develop his or her own vision.

 To quote an illustrator:
Now, if you include art in a picture book submission, the publisher will judge it according to the standards of the industry. That means, if you want ANY chance of being published, the art has to be of professional quality, good enough to hold its own on a bookshelf next to tons of other big books being published.

Now I am a little disappointed with this as you can imagine. DH said to self publish and use my own drawings. I am not so keen on this route, but if it means waving goodbye to my little friends I might have to consider it, I love them too much to push aside. They go hand in hand with the manuscript. I am not so sure I want to share half my royalties for pictures that I might dislike.

What shall I do?  
Do you know differently?






Sample snippets from Chewy Chester Meets Wallis Worm
Snippet 1
Snippet 2
Snippet 3

Meet more characters I have created for the book.  
Before they go into a file forever.

8 Comments:

Mason Canyon said...

I can understand why you might not want to self publish. However, I tend to agree with DH and say self publish. I'd hate for your cute illustrations not to be included. Best of luck.

Just a thought - can you self publish and then later submit the book to a publisher?

Mason
Thoughts in Progress

Glynis said...

Mason, it is so tempting. I just love my little characters, they have been part of the inspiration to write the book.
I had not thought of SP then submitting to a publisher. Something to consider.

Thanks for your support and encouragement. ♥

Len said...

Hello Glynis. I've seen the film, Beatrix Potter and I imagine your love of your character illustrations just like she did. I can't believe that they won't let an author have her own illustrations so I also agree with DH for you to self-publish. You know your characters more than anybody. Finding out if you could publish through a publisher after self-publishing might be useful. Will also search the internet and email you about it.

Glynis said...

Thanks Len! I self published my poetry through Lulu, but wanted so much to find an agent for Chewy. It might be a publisher's loss...LOL ♥

Alex J. Cavanaugh said...

Yeah, I knew publishers had their own illustrators and almost never use the author's work. But the press's graphic department will probably do something great. I was stunned when I finally saw my cover art - it was amazing. I guess it comes down to what's more important - your story or your illustrations?

Glynis said...

Alex, I had not really thought of splitting the two apart. It is something I am going to have to seriously consider. I appreciate illustrators, but just had my little pics in my mind. Time will tell, I am sure. Thanks for visiting me today. ♥

Mary said...

I would think there's a difference between genre illustrations. I agree with DH and Mason. Self-publish and maybe a publisher will pick it up intact.
Never knew illustrators got half -- that's an eye opener.
Good luck!

Ann Best said...

That is all true, of course, about illustrators; publishers pick whom they want.

It's a major decision for you to make. I always wish someone, in cases like this, would make my decision for me!

Good luck, whatever you decide to do.
Ann